Ethics Discussion from Textbook: Classic Readings and Cases in Philosophy of Law (1720 words)

  1. Home
  2. Homework Library
  3. Philosophy
  4. Ethics
  5. Ethics Discussion from Textbook: Classic Readings and Cases in Philosophy of Law (1720 words)

Question

Solution responds to the following questions:

1. Randall Kennedy, an African American law professor at Harvard, has written that identity politics is “mere superstition and prejudice.” “I eschew racial pride,” says Kennedy, “because of my conception of what should properly be the object of pride for an individual: something that he or she has accomplished. I can feel pride in a good deed I have done or a good effort I have made. I cannot feel pride in some state of affairs that is independent of my contribution to it. I did not achieve my racial designation” (Atlantic Monthly, May 1997, p. 56). Do you agree? Explain, indicating how you think Kymlicka and Young (Part 4, Chapter 18) might respond.

2. What impact has the Internet had on the freedom of speech? Is it good or bad that information is so readily available? In what ways do you think the Internet should be censored, if at all?

3. In what way does Nozick (Part 6, Chapter 15) think taxation is comparable to forced labor? Do you think he is right? Why or why not?

4. Using the essay by Lon Fuller in Part 6, Chapter 14, discuss the idea of the rule of law and the way(s) in which it is important for society to be ruled by law. (Note that "rule of law" does not simply mean there are laws--it means that no one can be punished for an action that was not clearly and publicly known to be illegal at the time the action is done. "Rule of law" also means that no government or public official is above the law.) If law does not guarantee justice or other values, then can it really be important? Explain.

Solution Preview

This material may consist of step-by-step explanations on how to solve a problem or examples of proper writing, including the use of citations, references, bibliographies, and formatting. This material is made available for the sole purpose of studying and learning - misuse is strictly forbidden.

Ethics Discussion Questions: Philosophy

1. Randall Kennedy, an African American law professor at Harvard, has written that identity politics is “mere superstition and prejudice.” “I eschew racial pride,” says Kennedy, “because of my conception of what should properly be the object of pride for an individual: something that he or she has accomplished. I can feel pride in a good deed I have done or a good effort I have made. I cannot feel pride in some state of affairs that is independent of my contribution to it. I did not achieve my racial designation” (Atlantic Monthly, May 1997, p. 56). Do you agree? Explain, indicating how you think Kymlicka and Young (Part 4, Chapter 18) might respond.

Kennedy’s argument is based on an ethics of meritocracy. He thinks a person should be valued on their accomplishments and not on any kind of racial marker. The sun, he quotes Cross as saying, should be proud of the hue of a person’s skin, and he contends an individual ought only to be proud of what they have actually done. Kennedy distinguishes racial pride from being ashamed of race. He says if racial pride means just that a person is not ashamed of the race they are born into, then he has no problem with this view. What Kennedy has issue with is favoring another person, or group of people on race alone. In a classroom, should a black professor invite only the black students to his office to socialize? Or, what about other signs of racial pride, that make it look, Kennedy says, that all persons of a particular race are brothers. Kennedy argues that a distinction is to be made between “family” and “race.” They are not the same thing. A person is your brother because over time you have formed a bond with this person. He may share the same race with you, and he may have the same biological parents as you, but Kennedy argues that what constitutes family goes beyond race and biology....

This is only a preview of the solution. Please use the purchase button to see the entire solution

Assisting Tutor

Related Homework Solutions

Get help from a qualified tutor
Live Chats